[The spider pauses. Considers this.]

..........y'know I ain't actually sure, I mean, we pulled th' eye out an' all, but I also pulled really hard...

[He looks a bit uncomfortable now. Fact is, there wasn't really time to think about it...aw dang did he kill someone Again???]

Nyhhh...man this isn't making any sense though, you didn't even get to meet the others until we were on that island!! How do we remember two differen' things like this!